4 Responses to “I Remember”

- Saqib Khan
- September 11th, 2009
Dear Chuck,
Innocent people losing their lives anywhere in the world is a tragedy indeed, this day is such a monentous point in post-war US history that it beggars belief that US schools aren’t taking the opportunity to reflect on this day about those who’ve lost so much on this day. For younger children they could tie in a theme of appreciating what you have right now, loved ones and perhaps freedoms that don’t exist in other parts of the world. For older children they could bring in greater themes about how despite what some might claim, there is no religion which justifies the killing of innocent people anywhere and not to assume what some misguided people do and say in the name of religion isn’t necessarily so and that we should keep open minds and open hearts.
As a British Muslim of Pakistani origin with a great many American friends, I’m every bit as sad for those who died on this day in New York City and elsewhere and for every US serviceman killed by a roadside bomb in Afghanistan and Iraq as I am any Palestinian, Afghan, Iraqi, or anyone else. I feel for all their mothers, wives, children, etc, left behind whose lives are forever changed for the worse in an instant.
In this holy month of Ramadhan, I say a prayer for rthem all and for the protection of the innocent wherever they are and for the wrong-doers to see the error of their ways. Having stayed with Southern Baptists friends in North Carolina in the past, I’ve always found more in common with committed Christians than I do with ignorant Muslims, no true man of god has hate in his heart or sees another as of less value to him, whatever his faith.
I pray God protects us all from the causes and effects of such terror.
Saqib

- chuck
- September 11th, 2009
Well stated, Saqib. Thanks for your unique perspective on this.

- Saqib Khan
- September 11th, 2009
I forgot to say in relation to the feable response you received from the teacher that whatever one’s beliefs, the only appropriate feelings run along the lines of immense sadness that this sort of thing could happen, empathy with those who have lost their most beloved and relief that our loved ones are as yet safe from harm, how could that offend anyone?
It these types of misguided and awkward stabs at political correctness that perpetuate and increases resentment toward communities that are assumed to be offended when we label such acts as horrific. It creates a sense of injustice of being wronged and then being censored when articulating reasonable sentiments of grief and regret.
Added to the outrage I’m sure most Americans felt/feel, there are a quiet majority of right minded Muslims like myself who also felt/feel outraged that their religion was so heinously hijacked for politically motivated terrorism. A great majority of us practice a personal and discreet brand of faith and are more focused on working hard to give our families security and a solid foundation of education for our kids than on any geo-political ambitions, just the sort of people whose voice is not dynamic enough to interest the mainstream media over the more attention capturing militant maniacs draping the cloak of islam over themselves.
All discussions on 9/11 don’t have to focus on geo-politics, one can introduce far greater themes like emphasising the commonality of all races and other concepts of humanity that the whole world would be better off adopting. My mother is a high school teacher in a London suburb and finds no problem in declaring how wrong the harming of innocents is, perhaps there is some value in sharing the thoughts of a Muslim in London with your child’s teacher, I don’t know…
PS. I’m grateful to Andy Rutledge for retweeting this, I really feel the need for people to know that Muslims out there understand your pain on such an occasion and even though personally innocent, feel both outraged and shamed by such wickedness.


Yeah I agree with Bryan on this one. To all those ppl who lost their lives…God Bless America.